The DSM Inclusion Debate

The psychiatrists working on the upcoming 2013 update of the Diagnostic Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders are currently debating whether to include parental alienation syndrome among its growing list of disorders.

According to an article in The Tennessean, Therapist’s split on ‘parental alienation’:

Parental alienation, as defined by [William] Bernet and more than 50 colleagues around the country and the world who are pushing for its inclusion in the reference tome, is a form of brainwashing that occurs only in a small number of highly contentious breakups.

A small number he says. I imagine it would occur in a growing number of households if the DSM made it a treatable disorder. Sure. Staying together for the sake of junior can be a good idea, or it can be a bad idea. If this sounds weird to you, not to worry, it sounds weird to me, too. Sometimes grownups have a hard time growing up. That’s life, that’s not medicine.

The concept has vocal critics who fear some decision-makers may not be able to distinguish parental alienation from genuine danger. But the scenario of one parent attempting to turn children against another is familiar to anyone who works in family law or counseling.

The fear is that mommy or daddy could really be a danger to the kids. This happens, and there is no need to dreg up the ghost of Robert Ripley to confirm. All you have to do is open up a newspaper.

You’ve got alienating parents, sure, but what about your alienating siblings? Shouldn’t we also have a sibling alienation designation? Can’t siblings also be a danger to other siblings? Sibling rivalries develop, and family scapegoats occur. I’m sure there must be some alienation involved in this matter, too.

Also, alienation is hardly restricted to the nuclear family. Why don’t we make social alienation an official disorder as well? Add social alienation syndrome as a DSM disorder, and the over all medicalization of modern society should be nearing completion. Of course, the question then becomes who is doing the brainwashing? Is it society at large, or is it the American Psychiatric Association membership behind each additional expansion of the DSM?

Cure alienation then, if it’s all a matter of brain washing. Uh huh, but is the brain washed brain the alienated brain, or is it the non-alienated (think smiley) brain? You will have to answer that one for yourself.

I haven’t gotten to psychiatric alienation yet, but just give me time.

Advertisements

4 Responses

  1. There is a sibling rivalry one!

    The DSM is increasingly becoming a joke among professional psychologists
    The effort being put forth on trying to submit so-called PAS into the new DSM, a legal tactic used by abusers to get custody of children, probably can be compared to the effort (or fraud) to others having the other ridiculous “mental conditions” added to the current DSM-IV:

    Stuttering

    Spelling Disorder

    Written Expression Disorder

    Mathematics Disorder

    Caffeine intoxication/Withdrawl

    Nicotine use/Withdrawl

    Sibling Rivalry Disorder

    Phase of Life Problem

  2. I have often thought of a “racial alienation syndrome.” I feel that a lot of people could relate. Finding this post offers a lot of comfort http://www.randijames.com/2009/12/anyone-can-diagnose-parental-alienation.html

  3. I like the way you look at this! Thanks for that straight forward approach as well.

  4. Maybe they (therapists who go for alienation ideas) can suggest a de[programming ranch for my cat. Another feline has alienated him. All because I wouldn’t share my turkey .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: