On finding another illness with little or no basis

One headline struck my consciousness as curious in recent weeks for exposing certain blatant weaknesses in current biological psychiatric theory. WebMD covered the story with an article titled, CDC: Morgellons Disease May Be Psychiatric Disorder. The truth of the matter is a little more profound than this headline suggests.

Extensive study of people suffering from Morgellons disease — including analysis of their mysterious “skin fibers” — finds no underlying cause of the illness.

If no physical cause to a disease can be found then it is deemed to be psychological in nature or, in other words, a “mental illness”. Now going from saying that it is “all in the head” to claiming it is a “disease of the brain”, and that it has a “genetic basis”, is quite some leap, but this is precisely the kind of leap, in presumption more than theory, that modern medical-model psychiatry is so adept at making. “Brain disease” being a physical cause, if “mental illness” were found to stem from a “brain disease”, psychiatrists would need to find another profession. Literally, a “mentally ill” person is a person who is suffering, or not functioning if you prefer, for a reason that has no known physical basis.

So just what the heck is Morgellons Disease?

Morgellons symptoms are as creepy as the name implies. Patients report slow-to-heal sores that often feel like bugs are crawling under their skin. They often scratch themselves raw. And they also report that mysterious colored fibers, granules, worms, eggs, fuzzballs, or other stuff comes out of their skin.

Somebody should make a list of dubious diseases someday, from fibromyalgia to restless leg syndrome, that give people with weak constitutions and temperaments an easy excuse for demanding special and specialized attention. I would wager it would become quite an extensive list in time if one looked long and hard enough into the matter.

Disease has not been ruled out in the case of Morgellons, but, and a long but it is…

They suggest that the patients’ symptoms and histories are similar to those of patients with a psychiatric condition called delusional infestation — the delusional belief that one is infested with parasites.

Now if these diseases, as there is no disease at all present, actually represent beliefs, it is actually this perceived need for a special or specialized attention that is the thing with which we must contend. I suggest that our society is not nearly as hearty as it once was due to the harboring of so many of these fallacious beliefs, and the humoring of so many people who have been so persuaded. When 1 in 5 people in the USA at the present date, according to recent reports, are said to be have contracted a “mental illness”, perhaps our efforts would be better directed at diverting a few more of this number from making such a radical conversion in faith.

One Response

  1. I’ll put this here for no real reason but to say that I have been learning that in Victoria (Au) more and more GP’s (ordinary suburban physicians) are becoming complicit with the shrinks by taking on and prescribing to people who have passed some kind of scrutiny and hence gone through the machine of acute psych hospital – psych clinic thing. The clinics probably get paid for both having and discharging supposed patients.

    I suspect that this is the case everywhere, so maybe you could check it out and blog about it.

    There is a guy in this neighborhood that I’ve seen in the street 10 times a week, for months, for five years that I have seen, at all times of day, walking. I’ve nodded and said “Hi” to him about 20 times, about 0.1 % of the number of times that I’ve actually seen him. Sometimes he walks by and I look the other way.

    Tonight he was right there as I was putting out the rubbish. Since I’m probably the first rational person he’s been addressed to in years, if ever, it’s not surprising that he was quickly, with some mild encouragement, quite forthcoming.

    He has the typically tedious manner of the drugged but with skilled questioning it became known (as if I didn’t really know) that he was being drugged fortnightly with risperidone and that if he objects, the gun thugs (the pigs, Victoria Police, probably female officers because they are all the more more stupid and revolting to the senses of a decent human) will drag him to the wack shack.

    I say it would be a good move to go after the GP’s.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: